BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER

TWN Info Service on WTO and Trade Issues (Nov26/11)
18 November 2026
Third World Network

WTO: Facilitator's questions raise concerns over move to steer LPF debate
Published in SUNS #10556 dated 17 November 2026

Geneva, 16 Nov (D. Ravi Kanth) -- The outgoing facilitator overseeing the discussions on the controversial World Trade Organization reform track on "level playing field" (LPF) issues has posed several questions to the coordinators of the least-developed countries (LDCs), the ACP (African, Caribbean, and Pacific) Group, and China to justify the specific concerns raised in their respective submissions, the SUNS has learned.

Several countries remain concerned that the questions raised by the outgoing facilitator, Ambassador Elmer Jose German Gonzalo Schialer Salcedo of Peru, appear to be an attempt at navigating the discussions to "water down" the concerns raised by the respondents, said trade envoys, who asked not to be quoted.

Instead of pinning down the original proponents of the "level playing field" issues, which is an offshoot of the trilateral agenda that was conceived by the United States, the European Union, and Japan to target China's state-trading enterprises and alleged subsidy schemes operated by Beijing, the facilitator appears to be acting on behalf of the major industrialized countries, envoys said.

"What is the rationale in sending the questions on late Friday evening (13 November) for a meeting that is going to take place less than 48 hours after," said an African envoy, who asked not to be quoted.

QUESTIONS

In a restricted room document (RD/GC/Reform/7), seen by the SUNS, the facilitator wrote that "to assist proponents in preparing and responding effectively to Members' questions, Members were encouraged, where possible, to submit questions on the proposals by Thursday, 12 November."

Ambassador Salcedo insisted that the questions are "intended as guidance only and is entirely optional."

He said that "members remain free to raise questions during the meeting itself," adding that "following this call, we have received the following questions for proponents on their written submissions:

LDC Group

To recall, The Gambia, which coordinates the least-developed countries, has raised several concerns. They include:

1. Mapping conducted to determine the problem and scope of areas deemed to impact the level playing field.

2. All areas must be discussed, not limited to one issue.

3. Address LDC capacity constraints through sustained support, not punitive measures. LDC notification and implementation challenges stem from limited institutional and financial capacity. Reform should prioritize long-term technical and financial assistance, streamlined notification systems, and continued access to WTO resources, including documents, while avoiding punitive measures that could further marginalize LDCs.

4. Participation in the WTO must include LDC access to all documents, convening notices, and other materials, regardless of arrears status. This should ensure that at any juncture during LDC Membership in the WTO, no LDC must struggle to catch up or be left behind.

5. Support LDC economic development and safeguard development-oriented flexibility. WTO reform should help expand LDC participation in global trade by strengthening productive capacity, skills, and technology transfer, preserving the benefits of preferential market access, and establishing measures to track LDC trade integration. In this regard, the WTO might consult with the LDC Group on a special digital trade clinic to assist LDCs in identifying options to improve the playing field for LDCs in this sector. The LDC Group will elaborate further, the possible mechanism and process that could be considered.

6. Improve services waiver preferences that can result in concrete market access in the services sector. Some of the results from the questionnaire exercise on consumers in preference providing Members and LDC suppliers could draw on some lessons learnt on improving the preferences.

7. Upholding predictability in the application of WTO rules, including security exceptions that are not used with negative repercussions on LDCs.

8. Strengthening transparency, timely information-sharing, and inclusive decision-making to enable effective LDC participation. LDCs should be fully consulted and involved in agenda-setting and negotiations, while all Members, particularly developed countries, should lead by example in fulfilling transparency obligations.

9. Providing or improving early alerts on measures affecting LDC exports, flexibilities to aid implementation in light of capacity constraints, and special assistance from the WTO Secretariat.

10. Considering the significant commitments already undertaken by acceded LDCs and ensuring a balanced system of rights and obligations. LDCs remain committed to the multilateral trading system and expect future reforms to reflect their development needs and implementation challenges. Implementation of the LDC Accession Guidelines should be part of the examination under this track.

11. Restoring a fully functioning two-tier dispute settlement mechanism.

However, the facilitator only posed questions on some issues that he raised, but not on the main issues like the delayed LDC services waiver,  "restoring a fully functioning two-tier dispute settlement mechanism", and the level of onerous accession commitments imposed on the poor countries, said an LDC official who asked not to be quoted.

The facilitator, for example, raised the following questions to The Gambia (LDC Group). The questions include:

* "The LDC Group has proposed a "mapping conducted to determine the problem and scope of areas deemed to impact the level playing field". Could the LDC Group elaborate on who would be responsible for leading and contributing to this mapping exercise, what is the expectation in terms of the depth and detail of the mapping exercise, and how could the mapping exercise be used to further advance discussions in the level playing field track?

* Acknowledging the need to address LDC capacity constraints and limited institutional and financial capacity, does the LDC Group consider it useful to concurrently consider other forms of incentives that could help improve notification submission by all Members?

* The LDC Group has proposed a "special digital trade clinic to assist LDCs in identifying options to improve the playing field for LDCs in this sector" adding that it will "elaborate further the possible mechanism and process that could be considered" to support economic development and safeguard development-oriented flexibility for LDCs. We would be keen to hear more details about the innovative proposal on the "special digital trade clinic" when available as well as any other ideas being considered if any.

* You propose that mapping is conducted to determine the problem and scope of areas deemed to impact the level playing field. What do you see as the scope of that exercise and who would conduct it?"

From the above questions, the facilitator has seemingly avoided asking the US, which is one of the main proponents of the LPF issues, to answer whether there can be any level playing field without a binding enforcement function involving the two-tier dispute settlement system?

ACP Group

On the questions posed by the facilitator to the ACP Group, it is important to highlight that the Group proposed (WT/GC/Reform/W/20) that "work under this [LPF] track should focus on all sectors of distortive subsidies [particularly agriculture]. The track must not presume distortion from state ownership or public support alone, impose automatic penalties for late notification, create new prohibited categories without balance across sectors and effective SDT [special and differential treatment], restrict development policy space without addressing structural and historical asymmetries, or legitimise measures inconsistent with WTO obligations."

However, the facilitator posed the following five questions to the ACP Group. They include:

1. "The ACP Group highlighted the need to "address structural and historical asymmetries" including "longstanding distortions in agriculture, fisheries and other sectors". To the extent that some of these issues are the subject of ongoing negotiations in other WTO bodies such as the Committee on Agriculture in Special Session and Negotiating Group on Rules, could the ACP Group clarify if it is proposing that these issues also be taken up in the Level Playing Field track, and if so, how we could avoid the duplication of discussions?

[The US, the EU, the farm-defensive countries led by Switzerland and Japan have opposed bringing the issue of agricultural subsidies into the LPF orbit].

2. The ACP Group has proposed an analytical approach where Members should, among others, identify the measure, the relevant WTO provision, available evidence of cross-border trade effects, and affected Members and sector. Could the ACP Group clarify how such an analysis could be used to advance discussions on level playing field given that different measures would affect Members and sectors differently?

3. The ACP Group has proposed an analytical approach in its paper, noting that it "must not modify existing agreements, including where proof of adverse trade effects is not required". Could the ACP Group clarify what this refers to, including through providing illustrative examples?

4. What role do you see for existing structures and committees as part of due process on notification compliance?

5. We agree on the importance of transparency and due process, including ensuring Members have the opportunity to be heard. How do you think the WTO could strengthen this in practice, and could existing mechanisms have a role to play?"

China

In his volley of questions to China, the facilitator seems to be raising the same concerns that the major industrialized countries have raised over China's proposal (WT/GC/Reform/W/22).

To recall, China has called for "fact-based rather than label-driven" approaches to various issues in this controversial track, which is the "brainchild" of the US, the EU, and Japan.

The facilitator posed several questions to China. They include:

1. China submitted that "the WTO could serve as a multilateral forum for dialogue and coordination on industrial policies from a trade and investment perspective" citing the success of the ongoing Member-Driven Conversations on Current Economic Issues. China also noted that "international coordination and mutual peer learning remains inadequate". In this connection, would China have any suggestions on how the WTO could help to facilitate international coordination on industrial policies beyond dialogue?

2. China noted that "Members hold divergent views and use different methodologies to define and assess the scope and effects of subsidies, further eroding mutual trust" and that "existing subsidy data and analytical studies remain highly contested". In this connection, would China have any suggestions as to how we can collectively advance fact-based and objective discussions to better understand the scope and effects of subsidies and industrial polices, including financing-related issues?

3. China proposed two possible questions for further deliberation, including on the need for targeted disciplines on additional forms of trade-distortive subsidies and how existing subsidy rules could be improved to better achieve legitimate public policy objectives, taking into account the impact on fair competition. Would China have any suggestions in terms of common principles in which Members should view the issue of "fair competition" when reflecting on these proposed questions?

4.  What practical steps could Members take to assess whether current disciplines adequately address the trade- distortive effects of modern industrial policies, while preserving legitimate development objectives?

5. The paper argues that fairness discussions should include government measures that distort trade and references possible updates to the ASCM. Where do you see the greatest gaps in the current multilateral framework, and what principles should guide Members in considering whether existing rules remain fit?

6. The old category of non-actionable subsidy lapsed in part because it was not used. It was also subject to governance (Article 9 of the ASCM) with the aim of providing a means to raise a challenge where subsidies were causing harm.  How do you believe this article could be updated to reflect a balance between legitimate policy objectives and managing potential adverse effects?

7. Does China foresee any particular terms of reference or rules of procedure to maintain fact-based dialogue at an industrial policy coordination mechanism?

8.  What specific outputs does China envisage from the mechanism that could support core function or future initiatives?

Paraguay

Lastly, the facilitator, apparently on behalf of the original proponents of the LPF issues, posed several questions to Paraguay.

To recall, in its proposal (WT/GC/Reform/W/23), Paraguay has brought agriculture to the forefront of the WTO reform discussions on LPF issues, emphasizing the need for "equity" and "the promotion of development through free trade".

The facilitator has asked Paraguay the following questions. They include:

1. Paraguay noted that "at present, certain measures, especially those that are ambiguous or multifaceted, cannot be addressed clearly or satisfactorily as part of the regular work of the Committees" and that "the current rules need to be clarified and strengthened, and additional  rules developed where necessary to address these measures and their impact when combined with other existing instruments". Could Paraguay clarify the scope of the WTO rules and Agreements where the current rules could benefit from further clarity and strengthening, including whether this extends beyond the Agreement on Agriculture?

2. Paraguay had proposed "discussing and agreeing on common parameters to assess the cumulative effect of measures that distort trade and production and skew the playing field, without prejudging the solutions". In addition to the principles of "equity" and "the promotion of development through free trade" identified by Paraguay, what are some examples of possible parameters that could be used to assess the cumulative effect of distortive measures, including to address the issue of non-tariff measures raised by Paraguay?

3. Paraguay had proposed to "assess measures to ensure a level playing field and reduce trade and production distortions". Could Paraguay clarify how such an assessment would be produced, and be used to advance further discussions in the level playing field track?

In short, the questions posed by the facilitator seem to be an alleged attempt to steer the discussions in a particular direction that is helpful to the major industrialized countries, said people familiar with the discussions. +

 


BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER