BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER

TWN Info Service on WTO and Trade Issues (Nov26/10)
18 November 2026
Third World Network

WTO: Attempts to alter consensus principle through chair appointments
Published in SUNS #10555 dated 16 November 2026

Geneva, 13 Nov (D. Ravi Kanth) -- A small group of countries has floated a proposal seeking "to enhance the process for appointment of chairpersons at the World Trade Organization as a case study of the practice of Decision-Making at the WTO", in what appears to be an attempt to change the consensus-based decision-making principle "by hook or by crook".

With the WTO reform discussions seemingly at an impasse, efforts appear to be underway to divide opposition among the majority of developing and least-developed countries to changing the consensus principle, among other issues, according to people familiar with the development.

The small group of WTO reform proponents has also proposed a draft General Council decision for adoption next month, allegedly to cover up the lack of progress in the reform discussions, said people who asked not to be quoted.

While some facilitators are apparently holding small-group meetings on issues such as the decision-making track, members are being kept in the dark about the discussions and the positions taken by various participants, said a person who asked not to be quoted.

Facing strong opposition to amending paragraph one of Article IX of the Marrakesh Agreement, Canada, Chile, New Zealand, Nigeria, Norway, Singapore, and Switzerland are proposing to use the ongoing efforts to improve the appointment process for WTO chairpersons as a case study in decision-making.

Paragraph one of Article IX of the Marrakesh Agreement states: "The WTO shall continue the practice of decision-making by consensus followed under GATT 1947. Except as otherwise provided, where a decision cannot be arrived at by consensus, the matter at issue shall be decided by voting. At meetings of the Ministerial Conference and the General Council, each Member of the WTO shall have one vote. Where the European Communities exercise their right to vote, they shall have a number of votes equal to the number of their member States which are Members of the WTO. Decisions of the Ministerial Conference and the General Council shall be taken by a majority of the votes cast, unless otherwise provided in this Agreement or in the relevant Multilateral Trade Agreement."

PROPOSAL

In their proposal (WT/GC/Reform/W/21), circulated on 2 November, the seven countries, some of which are vocal proponents of WTO reform, including New Zealand, whose trade envoy currently chairs the General Council, argued that "the appointment process for Chairpersons at the WTO, specifically for Tier-2 Chairpersons, has faced persistent and recurring delays in recent years."

Citing "the Guidelines for Appointment of Officers to WTO Bodies (WT/L/510)" adopted by the General Council on 11 December 2002, they noted that the guidelines provide that Members should regard the appointment exercise as a "relatively routine annual housekeeping function" to ensure that the WTO "... continues to be able to handle its business in a smooth and seamless way".

However, it remains questionable whether discussions on fundamental issues, including changing the principles enshrined in the Marrakesh Agreement, can be compared with the appointment of chairs of Tier-2 bodies. Such changes could undermine the multilateral framework and facilitate the incorporation of plurilateral agreements, said a trade envoy who asked not to be quoted.

The seven countries said that "the appointment process for Tier-2 Chairpersons has been challenged by difficulties in reaching consensus on the slate of candidates, including the most recent exercise for the appointment of Chairpersons for the Tier-2 bodies for 2026."

They maintained that "these recurring delays warrant attention, as further delays could continue to negatively impact the regular and smooth functioning of WTO bodies."

The proponents also lamented that "previous efforts to improve the appointment process for Chairpersons have also not yet resulted in any outcomes."

In the past, major industrialised countries were understood to have repeatedly blocked the appointment of candidates to various WTO bodies on grounds of their countries' positions, said a trade envoy who asked not to be quoted.

In their proposal, the seven countries suggested that "the current WTO Reform discussions on Decision-Making therefore provides an important opportunity for Members to review the appointment process for Chairpersons and discuss: (a) how decision-making can be improved using the appointment process for Chairpersons as an example; and (b) specific ways to improve the process through the proposed elements for a General Council decision."

"This could provide a practical and meaningful outcome under the Decision-Making track of the WTO Reform process," the seven countries argued.

Many developing countries view the proposal as "a subterfuge". They fear that agreement on the appointment of chairs could subsequently be used to change consensus-based decision-making, making it easier to incorporate plurilateral agreements, such as the Agreement on Electronic Commerce (ECA), which was launched without prior consensus under paragraph nine of Article X of the Marrakesh Agreement, said a trade envoy from a developing country who asked not to be quoted.

In what the trade envoy described as repeated attempts to divide the developing countries, all but one of the seven countries were among the initial proponents of WTO reform.

DECISION-MAKING

Under the subheading "How the WTO decision-making process can be improved using the appointment process for chairpersons as an example," the seven countries explained that "the appointment process for Tier-2 Chairpersons is initiated by the Chairs of the Council for Trade in Goods (CTG) and Council for Trade in Services (CTS)."

According to the reform proponents, the process "is conducted through an open invitation from the CTG and CTS Chairs to all Members for nominations of candidates for the Tier-2 bodies, either directly to the CTG and CTS Chairs or through their Regional Group Coordinators, where relevant".

"This is followed by consultations among Regional Group Coordinators, concerned Members, and the CTG and CTS Chairs, with a view to reaching consensus on the final slate of candidates for the Tier-2 Chairpersons."

The proponents suggested that "the appointment process for Tier-2 Chairpersons offers a practical case study to reflect on how we can strengthen decision-making through process improvements and tools to facilitate decision- making."

Several developing-country members strongly rejected the idea that this example could be used to change the consensus principle and turn the organisation into one serving the interests of a few members, while the rest of the membership is left to accept whatever is agreed by the major proponents of plurilateral initiatives, said developing-country trade officials who asked not to be quoted.

While inviting members to respond, the proponents also said that "at the same time, it would be useful to consider and identify tools that could facilitate decision-making by consensus".

They suggested that "this would guide the next part of our discussions on specific ways to improve the process for the appointment of Chairpersons."

The proponents have also proposed adopting "a General Council decision to improve the process for the appointment of Chairpersons" at next month's final General Council meeting for this year.

This comes against the backdrop of an apparent impasse across the four reform tracks: foundational issues, decision-making, development, and "level playing field" issues.

The proposed elements of the General Council decision are "based on the most recent draft General Council Decision on the Practical Steps to Enhance the Process for the Appointment of Officers to Certain WTO Bodies (WT/GC/W/950/Rev.7) circulated on 17 February 2025."

In their proposal, the proponents highlighted the following elements for a decision:

ELEMENTS FOR DECISION

The General Council,

Noting that, to date, the process of consultations on the appointment of officers to WTO bodies has been conducted based on the 2003 "Guidelines for the Appointment of Officers to WTO Bodies" (WT/L/510, "the Guidelines"), which are complemented by the statement delivered by the Chairperson of the General Council at its meeting of 25-26 July 2012 (JOB/GC/22, "the Practical Steps"), and which also reference the agreement reached by the Trade Negotiations Committee (TNC) at its first meeting on 28 January and 1 February 2002 regarding the appointment of chairpersons of the TNC and of the bodies established by it (TN/C/M/1),

Acknowledging that the appointment of chairpersons is crucial to our work at the WTO, and should be done without delay between successive chairpersons so as not to cause disruption,

Agrees to the following elements to enhance the implementation of the Guidelines for negotiating bodies established by the TNC and subsidiary bodies of the Council for Trade in Goods (CTG) and Council for Trade in Services (CTS), based on practical experiences to improve the efficiency of the appointment process, while respecting the overarching goal of an appointment process that preserves the overall balance of representation and is Member-driven, transparent, and inclusive:

1. For the negotiating bodies established by the TNC:

1.1. To ensure that our work at the WTO is not disrupted, the Chair of the General Council is encouraged to proceed expeditiously with the appointment of replacement Chairpersons for these processes as required. Once the approximate departure date for a Chairperson of a special session is known, the Chair of the General Council should begin consultations to nominate a successor without delay.

1.2. Where an active special session is without a Chairperson for more than 60 days, the Chair of the General Council may appoint an interim Chairperson from amongst the Membership, taking into account the views of Members. The interim Chairperson's role would be to ensure that meetings can continue to be held and the work of the special session is not adversely affected. The Chair of the General Council should continue to consult with Members to find a Chairperson as soon as possible. The interim Chairperson would be appointed for a period of three months, renewable in the absence of objections from Members.

2. For the subsidiary bodies of the CTG and CTS:

Nomination Process

2.1. At the General Council meeting held in October, the Chair will inform the Membership of the process for  the appointment of Chairpersons of WTO bodies and request that Regional Group Coordinators initiate the internal nomination process for their respective regional groups for Chairpersons of subsidiary bodies of the CTG and CTS. Regional Group Coordinators are encouraged to initiate this internal process as early as possible, including before the formal appointment process begins. Members which wish to nominate candidates should inform their Regional Coordinator as soon as possible thereafter. Current Chairpersons of subsidiary bodies may be nominated for a second term, where appropriate, including where supported by the relevant committee or otherwise agreed by Members. Nominations should be submitted by Regional Group Coordinators to the Chairs of the CTG and CTS as soon as feasible in January, and no later than upon agreement on the chairs of Tier 1 (Groups 1, 2, 4 and 5 per the Annex of the Guidelines).

2.2. Members which do not belong to a Regional Group should engage directly with the Chairs of the CTG and CTS, including on any nominations they wish to make, and these chairs should keep such Members updated during the nomination process.

2.3. Members should endeavour to propose only candidates whose expected term in Geneva would enable them to serve the full term of the appointment, i.e., at least one year. In proposing candidates, Members should provide, where possible, relevant information or justification supporting the nomination of the candidate for the specific subsidiary body or bodies, to facilitate consideration of the overall slate of candidates.

Consultation Process

2.4. Members of Regional Groups should ensure that their Regional Group Coordinators are entrusted to engage with other coordinators on their behalf. Regional Group Coordinators should ensure that their constituents are informed of the nominations being made, have the opportunity to convey priorities regarding candidates for subsidiary bodies, and are kept apprised of ongoing consultations. In this connection, Regional Group Coordinators should:

a. Consult all constituents before coordination meetings with CTG and CTS Chairs;

b. Provide timely updates to all constituents on the latest state of play, including after coordination meetings with CTG and CTS Chairs;

c. Circulate the proposed slate of candidates to all constituents  in advance of its circulation to the CTG and CTS Chairs, including to provide an opportunity for comments.

2.5. Members which do not belong to Regional Groups should engage directly with the Chairs of the CTG and CTS, who should keep these Members updated during the consultation process.

2.6. The selection process should focus on the qualifications of the candidates as contained in the Guidelines, while also taking into account overall balance, the technical qualification of the candidates and the fair distribution of opportunities for Members to contribute as Chairpersons. Members should continue to exercise the utmost restraint in raising objections to candidates on grounds that fall outside the Guidelines and Practical Steps, and  provide reasons for any objections.

2.7. Recalling Article 1.1 of the Guidelines, Members should bear in mind that the appointment process is intended to be a relatively routine function and that Members should remain flexible.

2.8. If consensus has not been achieved on a full slate of candidates by the closing of the agenda for the first General Council meeting of the year, the Chairs of the CTG and CTS will report to the Membership on the state of consultations and work with the Chair of the General Council, who will engage in consultations and endeavour to resolve the matter as soon as possible.

2.9. The Chairs of the CTG and CTS should ensure that the appointment of chairs of subsidiary bodies proceeds expeditiously to ensure there are no unnecessary delays to the usual work of the WTO. In exceptional circumstances, where such delays in appointing a Chairperson appear likely to disrupt the work of a subsidiary body, the Chair of the CTG or CTS, as relevant, will appoint a qualified interim Chairperson from among the Membership, taking into account the views of Members, relevant Committee practice, and the availability of previous Chairs to assume or continue in the position. The Chairs of the CTG and CTS should continue consulting Members to find a chair as soon as possible. The interim chair would be appointed for a period of three months, renewable absent objections from Members.

Committee-Level Process

2.10. Where the existing rules of procedure of the subsidiary bodies provide for the election of Vice- Chairpersons, Members should take steps to operationalise the election of a Vice-Chairperson who can step in to fill the role of Chairperson if the need arises. This effort would be undertaken by the Chairpersons of the relevant subsidiary bodies in consultation with Members. The basis for consideration of a Vice-Chairperson should include candidates who are able to fulfil the complete term of an appointment, i.e., for at least one year, as well as the qualification of the candidate.

2.11. Where, during the course of the year, an appointed Chairperson is no longer able to serve, the subsidiary body should consider the appointment of an interim Chairperson in accordance with the established practice, including to consider the appointment of a past Chairperson or another qualified candidate where the former is not possible. +

 


BACK TO MAIN  |  ONLINE BOOKSTORE  |  HOW TO ORDER