|
|
||
|
TWN
Info Service on Finance and Development (Nov26/03) Investor confidence and the right to development: The contradictions of global macroeconomic governance By Maria Syed and Bhumika Muchhala An unresolved tension in global economic governance One of the most pervasive phrases repeated by national policymakers as well as institutional chiefs at the 2026 annual meetings of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) and the World Bank held in Bangkok in October was that of “maintaining investor confidence”. Across discussions on macroeconomic stability, sovereign financing and public debt, the imperative of investor stability in an era of rising borrowing costs and an ever-intensifying fiscal squeeze is rendered almost equivalent to that of global stability. These concerns are not confined to developing countries. An IMF article stresses that advanced economies like the United States and France are also confronting higher sovereign yields, increasing interest payments and mounting spending requirements. Yet the spillovers extend beyond their borders. Higher benchmark yields in major economies, states the article, can affect financing conditions elsewhere, with significant implications for countries with more limited fiscal space and access to affordable external finance. For developing countries, this raises a broader question about the coherence of global macroeconomic governance: how can the pursuit of financial stability and investor confidence be reconciled with the financial resources, policy space and deployment of fiscal, exchange rate and monetary policy tools required to advance national development priorities? The tension is particularly significant when considered through the lens of the international human rights instrument of the right to development (RTD). The United Nations Declaration on the Right to Development recognises the right of people to participate in, contribute to and enjoy economic, social, cultural and political development. It also places clear responsibilities on States to create national and international conditions conducive to its realisation. The question is not whether financial stability matters for development. Predictable financing conditions and sustainable public finances are fundamental to long-term economic resilience. Rather, it is whether the frameworks through which financial stability is pursued adequately account for countries' different circumstances, the distribution of adjustment costs and the implications of macroeconomic decisions for development. The oft-concealed question then necessarily surfaces: financial stability for whom? Rising sovereign yields and the international transmission of fiscal pressuresThe IMF's World Economic Outlook and Global Financial Stability reports released in October highlight the deepening fiscal pressures of higher borrowing costs. Between February and September 2026, the average 10-year government bond yield across the G7 increased by more than one percentage point, reaching its highest level in nearly two decades. The IMF identifies several contributing factors, including the oil price shock, persistent inflation, stronger investment demand and higher expected future growth associated with artificial intelligence. It nevertheless emphasises that fiscal fundamentals remain central: high public debt, spending pressures and the prospect of substantial government bond issuance are putting upward pressure on the yields demanded by investors. The IMF also identifies a feedback relationship between public debt and interest rates. When debt is already high, rising policy rates can deepen fiscal deficits and exacerbate debt distress. At the same time, high debt burdens make market interest rates more sensitive to fiscal developments, while shorter debt maturities can intensify this relationship, as higher policy rates pass through more quickly to government borrowing costs. Therefore, rising interest payments represent an increasingly inflexible claim on public resources, leaving less room for public investment and social spending. They can also constrain governments' capacity to respond to economic shocks and crises, particularly as expenditure demands associated with defence, energy security and ageing populations increase. The IMF estimates that the effective average interest cost of government financing could rise from 2.3 per cent in 2021 to 3.7 per cent by 2031. In the United States, interest payments are projected to increase from approximately 2.8 per cent of GDP before the pandemic to 5.7 per cent in 2031. These developments illustrate the growing fiscal significance of debt service costs, including in economies with substantial financial and institutional capacity. UN Trade and Development (UNCTAD)’s 2026 A World of Debt report underscores the interest premium challenge: “This interest premium represents a developmental opportunity cost: higher rates translate into increased interest costs in budgets and less money being available to support development and climate agendas.” UNCTAD highlights that if the 94 developing countries that currently pay higher interest rates on their public debt than the average developed country could borrow at similar rates, they would collectively save almost US$500 billion each year in interest. Illustratively, it said, such savings could be employed to finance significant additional investments in economic, social and digital infrastructure and other development programmes, and help to put the sustainable development agenda back on track. The implications of higher interest rates for the real economy are also salient. Higher borrowing costs directly translate into greater pressure to earn foreign currency through exports and other financial inflows in order to meet debt servicing requirements as well as purchase essential imports. A failure to do so can result in foreign currency shortages, growth-restricting policy responses aimed at curbing imports and, in some cases, an inability to service the external debt. However, as volatile rifts in the multilateral trade regime have exemplified, a nation’s export revenue is far from stable or predictable, and typically entails natural resource extraction and exploitation. Crucially, the IMF warns that higher benchmark yields in major economies can spill across borders and worsen debt dynamics elsewhere. Fiscal developments in systemically important rich economies are therefore not solely domestic concerns. They can influence the financing conditions and policy choices of countries that have little influence over the factors driving those developments. And the consequences are not uniform. Advanced economies generally have deeper domestic financial markets and greater access to financing in their own currencies as well as emergency swap lines from coordinated reserve country central banks. Many developing countries face far more limited financing options, greater vulnerability to external financial conditions, a constant pressure to adjust to exogenous shocks and narrower fiscal buffers. The IMF estimates that interest payments in low-income countries already absorb more than 15 per cent of tax revenues, while other independent estimates highlight that debt servicing consumes almost 40 per cent of government budgets in low-income countries The urgency of these concerns was reflected in discussions surrounding the IMF and World Bank annual meetings. IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva urged national leaders, particularly in major economies, to rein in public spending and address rising borrowing costs as sovereign bond yields increased. Inflation remained a prominent concern amid new economic data from the United States and several European economies. The message was that governments could not assume that favourable financing conditions would persist indefinitely, and that delayed fiscal adjustment could make the eventual response more difficult. Similar concerns have emerged in the European Central Bank's policy discussions. In a speech on 5 November, ECB Executive Board member Isabel Schnabel argued that the central bank's ability to fulfil its price-stability mandate depends on robust fiscal and regulatory frameworks that preserve what she described as "monetary dominance". She called for governments to resist moves towards financial deregulation and emphasised the importance of credible fiscal pathways to contain risk premia and interest expenditure. She also highlighted the interaction between higher public debt, shorter debt maturities and the faster transmission of monetary tightening into government financing costs. Schnabel's remarks point to an increasingly entangled interconnection between fiscal policy, financial regulation and the operational capacity of central banks. They also reflect the concern that high public debt and financial sector vulnerabilities can complicate the conduct of monetary policy, particularly when inflationary pressures require a sustained response. Her recommendations included retaining flexibility in monetary policy, assessing shocks according to their implications for the projected inflation path, and maintaining a central bank balance sheet no larger than necessary. These discussions illustrate that the relationship between fiscal credibility and monetary policy is not simply a question of reduced public expenditure. It also concerns the institutional and financial conditions under which central banks can pursue price stability. However, the implications of fiscal adjustment and tighter financing conditions differ considerably across countries. For developing economies, where debt service obligations already absorb substantial public resources, the challenge is to maintain macroeconomic stability without further constraining essential public services and public investments and the capacity to respond to external shocks. Debt, climate vulnerability and development financingThe interaction between debt service obligations and development financing is particularly evident in the context of climate change. Climate-related disasters can disrupt production, damage infrastructure, increase food and energy import requirements, and generate substantial reconstruction costs. For countries with limited fiscal buffers, these effects can quickly translate into balance-of-payments pressures and additional borrowing requirements. The financing challenge is therefore not limited to mobilising resources after a disaster. It also concerns the availability of predictable financing before shocks occur, including resources for adaptation, resilient infrastructure and preparedness. The importance of pre-designed financial mechanisms with clear eligibility and access rules has been highlighted. Timely, needs-based liquidity could help countries finance essential imports and maintain critical expenditure during periods of disruption, reducing reliance on costly emergency borrowing. Proposals that have been discussed include shock-responsive debt clauses, regional financial safety nets, stronger support for the Loss and Damage Fund, and debt swaps designed to redirect resources towards climate, environmental and social priorities. Debt swaps can support specific objectives, but they are not a substitute for comprehensive approaches to sovereign debt resolution where debt burdens are unsustainable. Their usefulness depends on country-specific design, financing terms, technical capacity and measurable outcomes. The Bridgetown Initiative and the Chiang Mai Initiative offer examples of efforts to develop financial arrangements responsive to particular vulnerabilities and regional financing needs. Discussions on regional safety nets have also considered institutional design, resource mobilisation and the capacity to provide timely liquidity during periods of financial stress. These arrangements could help bridge short-term liquidity needs and longer-term development transformation. However, they should complement, rather than replace, adequate multilateral financing and broader measures to address unsustainable debt. Emerging investment priorities and access to productive opportunitiesThe growing role of artificial intelligence in global investment adds another dimension to the debate on fiscal space and rising debt. Discussions at the IMF meetings highlighted the importance of incorporating AI-related shocks into economic modelling, including their implications for credit investment, financial risks and future growth. The IMF's analysis identifies stronger investment demand and higher expected future growth associated with AI among the factors contributing to higher yields in advanced economies. These developments are taking place alongside substantial public borrowing requirements and existing debt pressures. For developing countries, the issue is also whether they have access to the finance, infrastructure, technology and productive capabilities required to participate in these developments which can have another dimensional effect on their fiscal space. It was reiterated that countries with deeper capital markets and established technological ecosystems may be better positioned to attract investment and capture productivity gains, even as many developing economies continue to face constraints in accessing affordable finance and technology and, importantly, in responding to the energy and food price shocks. This underlines the importance of considering investment in emerging technologies alongside the financing requirements of infrastructure, climate adaptation and industrial development. This raises another question of whether the changing global investment patterns will further widen differences in productive capacity and access to finance for the emerging and low-income economies tackling the pressures of debt distress and climate disasters, amongst other external shocks. Towards greater coherence between financial stability and the right to development The right to development provides a framework for considering these issues within a broader understanding of national and international economic responsibilities. It directs attention to whether countries have the resources, policy space and institutional conditions necessary to pursue development, and whether international arrangements facilitate or constrain their capacity to do so. There are several considerations to follow for multilateral policy discussions. First, the international spillovers of macroeconomic decisions in systemically important economies warrant greater attention. Higher benchmark yields and changes in global financing conditions can affect developing countries' debt dynamics and policy choices, even where the underlying pressures originate elsewhere. Second, assessments of fiscal and debt sustainability should take account of development financing requirements. This means considering not only the capacity to service existing debt, but also the investment needed to sustain productive capacity, essential services and climate resilience. Third, international financing arrangements should provide more predictable and accessible support for countries facing external shocks. Pre-arranged liquidity, concessional financing, effective debt resolution mechanisms and adequately financed climate support can reduce reliance on costly emergency borrowing. Finally, developing countries should have meaningful opportunities to participate in shaping the rules and institutions that influence their financing conditions and development prospects. Regional cooperation, South-South initiatives and borrower coordination can strengthen this participation, while multilateral institutions remain essential to addressing systemic financing challenges. Conclusion: Financial stability in support of developmentThe growing emphasis on investor confidence and fiscal credibility reflects genuine concerns about rising public debt, higher borrowing costs and the sustainability of public finances. The research and analysis demonstrates that these pressures are increasingly significant in major advanced economies, while also identifying the international transmission of higher benchmark yields and the particularly heavy interest payment burden facing low-income countries. The implications are not uniform. Countries differ in their access to finance, their capacity to absorb shocks and their ability to adjust fiscal and monetary policies without undermining development priorities. These differences need to be recognised in international approaches to macroeconomic stability and debt sustainability. Hence, for emerging and developing economies, the challenge is to manage external financing pressures while maintaining the investment, public services and institutional capacity required for long-term development. This cannot be addressed solely through domestic adjustment. It also requires international arrangements that recognise cross-border spillovers, provide timely and affordable financing and enable countries to participate meaningfully in shaping the rules governing the global economy. The question for global macroeconomic governance is therefore not simply how countries can maintain investor confidence, but how financial stability can be pursued in ways that support the right to development. Its effectiveness should be assessed not only by the confidence of financial markets, but also by whether developing countries retain the resources, policy space and agency required to advance the development priorities of their populations.
|
||